OK. Let's play a hypothetical game for a moment here.
Pretend that you're Ron Washington, and your ballclub is down three runs in the bottom of the 9th. Pitching for the opposition is Joe Borowski, a right-handed closer who has 26 saves for the Indians this year, but also has a less than sparkling 5.15 ERA in 36.2 innings. His WHIP is a mediocre 1.39 coming into the game, and opposing batters are hitting .299 off of him. In short, he's been one of the worst closers in baseball in 2007.
Your leadoff hitter, Kenny Lofton, just dropped down a beautiful bunt single with one out in the bottom of the 9th inning. That means that the potential tying run is approaching the on-deck circle, in the person of Mark Teixeira, with just one man out. The bottom line is, you've got to find a way to get at least one more guy on base, so that you can bring that potential tying run to the plate.
Scheduled to bat next is Jerry Hairston; despite the unbridled and somewhat endearing emotion he's shown on the field this year, the fact remains he's not a good hitter. Hairston is batting .218/.279/.347 on the year overall, and a horrific .167/.256/.318 against right-handers. I'm sure Buck Showalter would love his grit.
On your bench is Frank Catalanotto, a guy who had a rough start (like most of the Rangers) this year, but has slowly come around offensively. For his career, Catalanotto is batting a more than solid .299/.362/.462 against right-handers. He's the best left-handed bat on your bench by a mile, and his ability to make contact makes him an excellent pinch hitting weapon for a situation just like this.
Batting in the cleanup spot behind Teixeira is Sammy Sosa, who got the start against left-hander C.C. Sabathia tonight. That's certainly not a problem; Sammy's been very good against left-handed pitching this year. Unfortunately, he's hitting a miserable .213/.248/.404 against right-handers. He also hasn't homered since June 30th in Boston.
If you're Ron Washington here, what should you do? Well, it would make the most sense to pinch hit Catalanotto for Hairston; after all, there's a pretty decent chance that Catalanotto reaches base, which would make Teixeira the tying run at the plate with nobody out.
Having Sammy batting behind Tex really isn't the greatest thing in the world, but with Michael Young absent from the team and the Rangers down to a 24-man roster, it's probably the best you can do. Your other pinch hitting options are Desi Relaford and Adam Melhuse, both of whom leave much to be desired.
One big advantage to letting Catalanotto bat for Hairston - since you're probably not feeling comfortable with putting Cat at a position (2B) that he hasn't played since 2002, you can easily slot in Relaford at second in the event the game goes to extra innings. That's a long way off, though, and you're concerned at the moment with just tying the game.
Batting Catalanotto for Sosa isn't quite as great of an idea, but hey, it's not like Sammy can hit right-handers much better than Hairston anyway. So, yeah, it would make sense for Ron Washington to use Catalanotto at some point in the 9th inning, both from a logistical and statistical standpoint.
Too bad I didn't have Ron's cell phone number during the 9th inning.
Washington let Hairston bat, who weakly popped out to right field. Lofton stole second base, and Teixeira lined a sharp single to right field, putting the tying run at the plate with two outs. Once again, Washington passed up Catalanotto and opted for Sammy, who rewarded Ron's confidence in him with a swinging strikeout to end the game. Queue several seconds of deafening silence in the FSN TV booth from Josh Lewin and Tom Grieve.
You know, I really like Ron Washington. I think he's a quality guy, and I believe he's got the knowledge and talent to become a very good major league manager someday. But his failure to pinch hit Frank Catalanotto in the bottom of the 9th inning for either Hairston or Sosa, two downright lousy hitters, is just mind-numbing. And while Ron's in-game management isn't near as bad as Buck's was near the end of his tenure, it still needs quite a bit of work.
To be fair, I probably wouldn't have written this long diatribe had one or both of Hairston and Sosa reached base, and Ron Washington certainly wouldn't have looked as clueless. But even if they had, it was still a bad decision to leave a good left-handed hitter on the bench against Borowski, who has a 1.47 WHIP allowed against left-handers this season.
And while I'm at it, let me say this: I really like Sammy Sosa, too. I was stoked when he clubbed home run #600, and I've always been a fan of his style of play and personality. I've grown so sick of the steroids talk surrounding Sosa and others from his era that I just don't care anymore about the whole media-driven steroids debate. I find it much more fun and relaxing to just watch a game and not wonder if a certain player is on some kind of performance enhancing substance. But I digress.
The bottom line is, Sammy is no longer an everyday, major league caliber baseball player. I think he can still be a nice lefty masher for some club out there, but he does not need to be hitting against right-handed pitching - ever again. The Rangers need to move on here sooner than later, and while I'm sure Jon Daniels dreads the thought of humiliating Sammy and his family by outright releasing him, he may have no choice but to do so. Something has got to give here.
To be honest, though, this game was lost by poor starting pitching, not poor in-game management. Kameron Loe gave up four runs in an ugly 2nd inning, which immediately put Texas in a big hole. The Rangers responded in the next half inning; with two outs, Brad Wilkerson doubled, Gerald Laird homered, Ramon Vazquez doubled, and Travis Metcalf singled to reduce the deficit to 4-3. Lofton lined out hard to third base to end the threat.
The Rangers tied the game in the bottom of the 4th, after Metcalf hit a sacrifice fly to deep center field with the bases loaded and nobody out. With men on 1st and 2nd and one out, Lofton hit a bullet up the middle that second baseman Josh Barfield managed to snag and turned into an 6-4-3 double play, denying the Rangers a lead. They never got to hold one in this game.
Loe ran into more trouble in the top of the 5th, surrendering a leadoff home run to Grady Sizemore and a triple to Casey Blake. Cleveland left the inning with a 6-4 lead, and tacked on an insurance run against Frankie Francisco in the 8th inning. Don't look now, but the Snake has now turned in two pretty bad starts in a row. I'm going to assume these last two starts have been a fluke, but I'd be lying if I said I wasn't just a bit nervous.
In the end, this game was all about missed opportunities. Texas had men on base all night, seemed to hit the ball hard all night, and came away with only four runs. This was a very winnable game, but hey, that's baseball I guess.
The DMN's Tim Cowlishaw has a new piece out tonight, and he believes Jon Daniels should make dealing Teixeira his top priority, while holding on to Eric Gagne and Aki Otsuka. I don't necessarily disagree, but it sounds like Cowlishaw is in a "We've gotta deal him no matter what" state of mind concerning Tex, and that's a rather dangerous mindset to be in. Needless to say, I'm glad Cowlishaw isn't the Rangers GM. He'd have us trading Tex for Tony Gwynn Jr. or some mess like that.
Tim also has includes this paragraph concerning Lofton and Sosa:
Getting something for Sosa or Lofton ranks farther down the list than moving Teixeira. There's something kind of fun about seeing Sosa winding down his career with the team that initially signed him.
Again, it's been fun having Sammy here this season. The fun begins to wear off when he starts costing you wins.
Texas will look to turn their fortunes around on Friday night, as Cleveland's Fausto Carmona takes on Brandon McCarthy.
Let's hope the dreaded "Curse of the Four Run Inning" doesn't strike the Rangers' starting pitching for a third straight game.
Friday, July 20th Game Preview
Cleveland Indians (56-39) at Texas Rangers (41-54)
F. Carmona (11-4, 3.77 ERA) vs. B. McCarthy (4-6, 5.59 ERA)
7:35 PM CST in Arlington, Texas (Rangers Ballpark in Arlington)
TV: FSNSW | Radio: KRLD 1080 AM