What is your opinion of the A.J. Pierzynski signing?
MJH on accountability
So the NHL is running their all-star game like a pick-up game with two captains picking/drafting their team out of the all-star talent pool. If MLB adopted this format (and you and your clone were the two captains), who would you pick? Feel free to make up a list for two teams and actually pick it like it's for two teams. Or you could just pick five pitchers for each team. Or just pick the top position players you would want. Or just talk about players you like. I guess I'm just curious about what players everyone here thinks are really the best.
Joaquin Arias.Joaquin Arias.
HA! But seriously, would you pick a pitcher or a bat first? Part of me would be tempted to pop Joe Mauer first.
Well, if you get Mauer, I get Big Time Timmy Jim.
First player I take is Halladay. If I wanted a bat, I would take Josh Hamilton.
I would try to get the best defense I possibly could. So, naturally, I would take Jeter.
Notify me of follow-up comments via email.